The Impact Index
Create a free account Saved list, your reports and more

GUIDE · W-R2

Subscription Traps, Coaching Schemes, Fake Reviews: 31 Cases Where Regulators Stepped In

31 closed cases from six countries against small and mid-size firms: coaching schemes, debt relief, subscription traps, fake reviews. Each with agency, date and a verbatim quote.

Whether you give money as a donation or as a purchase, it helps to know who you are dealing with. Here are 31 firms that regulators or courts acted against. Every case is closed.

How this list was made

We do not judge anyone ourselves. Every entry rests on an official source, and each quote appears word for word at the linked page. We checked this by machine on 3 and 4 November 2026.

We only list closed cases: judgments, final fines, court-approved settlements. Open lawsuits are left out on purpose. A settlement is not a finding of guilt, and we say which it was.

Review sites do not count as evidence. We name firms, not people. If you think an entry is wrong, you can object through report a correction.

Coaching and get-rich-quick

The most common scheme in FTC files: expensive programmes promising your own online business.

Zurixx, LLC (16 February 2022). The operators of a real estate investment coaching scheme “face permanent bans”, according to the FTC. Settlement with the FTC and the state of Utah. FTC

Ecommerce Empire Builders (9 May 2025). The FTC says its lawsuit “has put a stop to Ecommerce Empire Builders”. Settlement with a permanent ban. FTC

FBA Machine, formerly Passive Scaling (30 July 2025). The owner “will be permanently banned from selling business opportunities”. FTC

Automators AI (27 February 2024). A money-making scheme that “claimed to use artificial intelligence to boost earnings”. Settlement with a lifetime ban for the owners. FTC

Fat Giraffe Marketing Group LLC (“Cash From Home”, 14 February 2019), Internet Teaching and Training Specialists, LLC (9 January 2018) and Dahm International LLC (30 April 2018). In all three settlements the FTC banned the sale of business coaching. FTC on Cash From Home, FTC on ITT Specialists, FTC on Dahm

Debt relief and credit repair

These hit people who are already short of money.

Start Connecting LLC (“USA Student Debt Relief”, 22 May 2025), Student Advocates Team LLC (17 May 2021) and Arete Financial Group (9 September 2020). Three student loan “relief” operations, all ended in settlements, some with permanent industry bans; Arete pays at least $835,000. FTC on Start Connecting, FTC on Student Advocates, FTC on Arete

Prime Marketing Holdings, LLC (31 August 2017). According to the CFPB, “permanently banned from doing business within the credit repair industry”. CFPB

Daniel A. Rosen, Inc. (“Credit Repair Cloud”, 12 August 2024). Stipulated final judgment with a $1 million civil penalty for the company. CFPB

A&M Group Pty Ltd (“Debt Negotiators”, Australia, 21 December 2022). The Federal Court found it “engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct and in undue harassment or coercion against debtors”. Penalty A$650,000. ASIC

Law Debt Collection (New Zealand, 1 July 2025). Convicted and fined for misleading conduct after pleading guilty. Commerce Commission

Fake reviews and fake discounts

Cure Encapsulations, Inc. (26 February 2019). The FTC’s first case against paid reviews on an independent retail site: the defendants “paid a website, amazonverifiedreviews.com, to create and post Amazon reviews”. Settled by court order. FTC

TrendX (Netherlands, 9 December 2022). The Dutch consumer authority ACM fined the web shop €100,000 for misleading consumers. ACM

T.O.M. B.V. (Netherlands, 12 February 2019). The highest administrative court for trade upheld the ACM fines in the last instance. ACM

Day Trayders (koopjedeal.nl, Netherlands). €163,000 fine for fake discounts, upheld by the court in 2025. ACM

Walond Limited (“Look Sharp”, New Zealand, 19 February 2025). Fined NZ$292,500 “after pleading guilty to making misleading representations about product prices”. Commerce Commission

Buy It Direct Ltd (“Appliances Direct”, UK, 12 October 2026). The CMA “has imposed a financial penalty of £1,200,000”. CMA

Gyms and cancellation traps

Aneva Gym (New York, 4 August 2025). The gym “will change its cancellation policies”, refund customers who could not easily cancel, and pay a $5,000 penalty. NY AG

Gold’s Gym (UK) Limited (29 September 2026). A £45,000 CMA penalty “for infringing consumer protection law”. CMA

CityFitness Group Ltd (New Zealand, 9 June 2026). Convicted after “intentionally breached the Fair Trading Act”, fined NZ$1.12 million over a misleading transaction fee. Commerce Commission

Supplements and health claims

NatureCity, LLC (16 October 2019). The court order “bars the defendants from making false and unsubstantiated health claims”. FTC

Nobetes Corporation (4 December 2018). Settlement over unsubstantiated health claims for a dietary supplement. FTC

Roca Labs, Inc. In 2018 a federal court granted the FTC summary judgment; refunds went out in 2025. FTC

Telemarketing, tech support and crowdfunding

Elite IT Partners, Inc. (10 December 2019). “Permanently banned from offering tech support products and services to consumers”. FTC

Mega Byte Information (Canada, 6 February 2017) and Thompson Hill Publishing (Canada, 23 May 2017). Both pleaded guilty in the Court of Québec over deceptive telemarketing, fined C$450,000 and C$180,000. Competition Bureau on Mega Byte, Competition Bureau on Thompson Hill

Altius Management (Washington, 27 July 2015). A $54,851 judgment because Kickstarter backers never got their rewards. The attorney general: “Washington state will not tolerate crowdfunding theft”. WA AG

ACBF Funeral Plans Pty Ltd (Australia, 6 September 2023). A$1.2 million penalty “for misrepresenting the sale and promotion of funeral expense insurance to Aboriginal people”. ASIC

How to spot such offers

The cases look alike: big promises (fast money, debt freedom, cures), pressure to sign now, cancellation that is hard to find, reviews that sound too good. If you notice one of these, search the firm’s name together with the relevant regulator first.

For charities there are watchdogs. What they check is on our watchdogs page, and which regulators have acted against fundraisers is in this article.

A firm that is missing from this list is not thereby checked or safe. The list only shows what regulators made public.