The Impact Index
Create a free account Saved list, your reports and more

METHODOLOGY · THE TRUST HUB

How we count

The Impact Index shows what people, foundations, and companies demonstrably do for the good.

The word demonstrably is the core of this page. So here is exactly what we count, what we do not, and why.

A note on scope: the directory and its cost-ratio figures describe the German (and wider DACH) charity landscape. Several of the sources and thresholds below, including the German Institute for Social Issues (DZI, Deutsches Zentralinstitut für soziale Fragen), are specific to that market. We are building this page and the underlying data for an international audience, but the current methodology speaks primarily to Germany.

RULE 01

We only count what is documented

Every entry in the Impact Index carries a public source: a press release, an annual report, a signed Giving Pledge letter.

Without a source, there is no entry. We enforce this technically: our database will not accept an entry that has no source attached.

Every entry shows its source, its date, and its verification status. You can look up every figure yourself.

THE MOST IMPORTANT PARAGRAPH ON THIS PAGE

A missing entry means: nothing

If a person does not appear in our lists, that only means we have no public source for them. It does not mean that person gives nothing.

Many people choose to give quietly, and that deserves respect. The Impact Index recognizes documented giving. It does not judge anyone for the absence of documentation.

SOURCES

Where our data comes from

For the organization directory, we rely on assessments by the German Institute for Social Issues (DZI), the self-commitments of the Initiative Transparente Zivilgesellschaft, and the organizations' own annual reports. All three are German institutions, which is why the directory currently focuses on organizations active in Germany.

For the impact lists, we evaluate primary sources: press releases, foundation reports, the Giving Pledge, and reporting from reputable outlets with a traceable source of their own.

Every figure on this site carries its reporting year. A cost ratio stays labeled with the exact year it came from, even as that year recedes into the past.

CONTEXT

Why a low administrative cost ratio is not the whole story

We publish fundraising and administrative cost ratios because you have a right to know them.

But we say plainly: a low ratio does not prove good work, and a higher one does not prove bad work. Careful project selection, fair pay, and clean bookkeeping all cost money.

The DZI treats ratios up to 30 percent as acceptable and under 10 percent as low. We place every figure in that frame instead of letting the number speak for itself.

WARNINGS

When we point to a warning

We do not write our own warnings or raise our own suspicions.

If the DZI withdraws an organization's seal or publishes an adverse finding, we link to that official assessment. The judgment stays with the reviewing body; we just make it easy to find.

CORRECTIONS

Found a mistake? Tell us

We work carefully, but we are not infallible.

If a figure is outdated, a source is wrong, or a document is missing, report it through the correction form. We review every report and correct the record publicly, with a note explaining the change.

We are also glad to take new sources. If you know of a documented donation we are missing, send us the source.

DISPUTES

If you are listed here yourself

If you represent a listed organization, or you appear in one of our lists yourself and disagree with an entry, get in touch through the correction form and mark the report as a dispute.

We confirm receipt within 48 hours and review disputes with priority. Until the matter is resolved, we mark the affected entry as "under review."

Organisations can claim their profile in an account and submit documents such as an annual report or a seal. The editorial team checks each document against its public source. It only appears after approval, with source, review date and the label "verified". A claimed profile has no influence on rankings, ordering or review status: only documented values count there, under the same rules as for everyone.

CADENCE

How often we review

We review directory entries at least once a year, as soon as the new annual reports and the current DZI bulletin become available.

Every page shows its verification date. If a figure is older than its most recent available reporting year, we label it as outdated instead of letting it stand unremarked.

SCOPE

What the Impact Index is not

We are not a seal of approval and not a reviewing body. We do not assign grades, and we do not make donation recommendations.

We make existing sources and official reviews easy to find and understand. The decision on whom to trust stays with you, and our sources let you make it with the full picture.

GOVERNANCE

Who is behind the Impact Index

Who runs this project, who writes here, and how to reach us is on the About us page.

Provider, location, and funding are listed below as open placeholders. We will fill them in before public launch and state them there in the same words as on the About us page.

EDITORIAL PLACEHOLDER · TO BE COMPLETED BEFORE LAUNCH

This information is still missing. We show the gap openly rather than let it stay silently missing: a methodology page with gaps is more honest than one with invented answers.

  • Provider [PROVIDER NAME / AGENCY]
  • Location [LOCATION]
  • Funding [STATE THE MONETIZATION HONESTLY, e.g. no revenue at present or labeled partner links]
  • Last reviewed [DATE]

A missing entry means nothing. It only means we have no public source for it.