The Impact Index
Create a free account Saved list, your reports and more

KNOWLEDGE · W-04

What Is a Restricted Donation?

What a purpose restriction legally means, when it makes sense, and why an unrestricted donation to a vetted organization is often the better choice.

You donate 100 euros “for earthquake relief.” That makes it a restricted donation (zweckgebundene Spende), perhaps without your knowing it.

Here we explain what that means legally under German law and when it is a smart move.

The definition

A donation is restricted when you specify how it is used: for a particular project, a region, an occasion.

This restriction is binding. The organization must use your money for exactly that purpose, or it risks having to repay it and trouble with its nonprofit status (Gemeinnützigkeit).

Without a stated purpose, your donation is unrestricted, and the organization uses it where the need is greatest.

When a restriction makes sense

When a specific project is close to your heart and you want to support exactly that work.

Or when you give to an organization for the first time and want to build trust through a clearly defined project. Both are legitimate, and reputable organizations honor the restriction meticulously.

The catch: help in the wrong place

A restriction has a side effect that hardly anyone considers. After major disasters, more restricted money often comes in than the specific emergency response can use.

Then money sits locked while the neighboring crisis gets nothing. The organization cannot reallocate it, even when that would make sense.

Some organizations therefore deliberately word their appeals more broadly, for example “for emergency aid worldwide.” That is not a trick, but learned flexibility.

Our position

If you have vetted an organization, you can also trust it with deciding how to use your money.

That is why we usually recommend the unrestricted donation: it works even where no camera is pointed, and it still works when the headlines are over. A restriction remains the right tool for a specific personal wish, not the default case.

Frequently asked questions

Can I check afterward whether my restricted donation was used properly? Through the organization’s project reports and annual reports. Reputable ones report per project, and when a project is overfunded, they ask whether your money may be reallocated.

What happens to restricted money when the project ends? The organization must ask you or return the money if the purpose can no longer be fulfilled. Many therefore ask for permission to reallocate right in the donation form, so the fine print is worth a look.


Sources: Abgabenordnung (German Fiscal Code), §§ 51 ff. (tax-privileged purposes), as of 10/2026.

Last checked: October 3, 2026 · Author: Impact Index Editorial Team